| 1967 | X001I | Green Bay Packers | Kansas City Chiefs | 35-10 | Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum - Los Angeles, CA |
| 1968 | X002II | Green Bay Packers | Oakland Raiders | 33-14 | Orange Bowl - Miami, FL |
| 1969 | X003III | New York Jets | Baltimore Colts | 16-7 | Orange Bowl - Miami, FL |
| 1970 | X004IV | Kansas City Chiefs | Minnesota Vikings | 23-7 | Tulane Stadium - New Orleans, LA |
| 1971 | X005V | Baltimore Colts | Dallas Cowboys | 16-13 | Orange Bowl - Miami, FL |
| 1972 | X006VI | Dallas Cowboys | Miami Dolphins | 24-3 | Tulane Stadium - New Orleans, LA |
| 1973 | X007VII | Miami Dolphins | Washington Redskins | 14-7 | Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum - Los Angeles, CA |
| 1974 | X008VIII | Miami Dolphins | Minnesota Vikings | 24-7 | Rice Stadium - Houston, TX |
| 1975 | X009IX | Pittsburgh Steelers | Minnesota Vikings | 18-6 | Tulane Stadium - New Orleans, LA |
| 1976 | X010X | Pittsburgh Steelers | Dallas Cowboys | 21-17 | Orange Bowl - Miami, FL |
| 1977 | X011XI | Oakland Raiders | Minnesota Vikings | 32-14 | Rose Bowl - Pasadena, CA |
| 1978 | X012XII | Dallas Cowboys | Denver Broncos | 27-10 | Superdome - New Orleans, LA |
| 1979 | X013XIII | Pittsburgh Steelers | Dallas Cowboys | 35-31 | Orange Bowl - Miami, FL |
| 1980 | X014XIV | Pittsburgh Steelers | Los Angeles Rams | 31-19 | Rose Bowl - Pasadena, CA |
| 1981 | X015XV | Oakland Raiders | Philadelphia Eagles | 27-10 | Superdome - New Orleans, LA |
| 1982 | X016XVI | San Francisco 49ers | Cincinnati Bengals | 26-21 | Silverdome - Pontiac, MI |
| 1983 | X017XVII | Washington Redskins | Miami Dolphins | 27-17 | Rose Bowl - Pasadena, CA |
| 1984 | X018XVIII | Los Angeles Raiders | Washington Redskins | 38-9 | Tampa Stadium - Tampa, FL |
| 1985 | X019XVIX | San Francisco 49ers | Miami Dolphins | 38-16 | Stanford Stadium - Stanford, CA |
| 1986 | X020XX | Chicago Bears | New England Patriots | 46-10 | Superdome - New Orleans, LA |
| 1987 | X021XXI | New York Giants | Denver Broncos | 39-20 | Rose Bowl - Pasadena, CA |
| 1988 | X022XXII | Washington Redskins | Denver Broncos | 42-10 | Jack Murphy Stadium - San Diego, CA |
| 1989 | X023XXIII | San Francisco 49ers | Cincinnati Bengals | 20-16 | Joe Robbie Stadium - Miami, FL |
| 1990 | X024XXIV | San Francisco 49ers | Denver Broncos | 55-10 | Superdome - New Orleans, LA |
| 1991 | X025XXV | New York Giants | Buffalo Bills | 20-19 | Tampa Stadium - Tampa, FL |
| 1992 | X026XXVI | Washington Redskins | Buffalo Bills | 37-24 | Metrodome - Minneapolis, MN |
| 1993 | X027XXVII | Dallas Cowboys | Buffalo Bills | 52-17 | Rose Bowl - Pasadena, CA |
| 1994 | X028XXVIII | Dallas Cowboys | Buffalo Bills | 30-13 | Georgia Dome - Atlanta, GA |
| 1995 | X029XXIX | San Francisco 49ers | San Diego Chargers | 49-26 | Joe Robbie Stadium - Miami, FL |
| 1996 | X030XXX | Dallas Cowboys | Pittsburgh Steelers | 27-17 | Sun Devil Stadium - Tempe, AZ |
| 1997 | X031XXXI | Green Bay Packers | New England Patriots | 35-21 | Superdome - New Orleans, LA |
| 1998 | X032XXXII | Denver Broncos | Green Bay Packers | 31-24 | Qualcomm Stadium - San Diego, CA |
| 1999 | X033XXXIII | Denver Broncos | Atlanta Falcons | 34-19 | Pro Player Stadium - Miami, FL |
| 2000 | X034XXXIV | St. Louis Rams | Tennessee Titans | 23-16 | Georgia Dome - Atlanta, GA |
| 2001 | X035XXXV | Baltimore Ravens | New York Giants | 34-7 | Raymond James Stadium - Tampa, FL |
| 2002 | X036XXXVI | New England Patriots | St. Louis Rams | 20-17 | Superdome - New Orleans, LA |
| 2003 | X037XXXVII | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | Oakland Raiders | 48-21 | Qualcomm Stadium - San Diego, CA |
| 2004 | X038XXXVIII | New England Patriots | Carolina Panthers | 32-29 | Reliant Stadium - Houston, TX |
| 2005 | X039XXXIX | New England Patriots | Philadelphia Eagles | 24-21 | Alltel Stadium - Jacksonville, FL |
| 2006 | X040XL | Pittsburgh Steelers | Seattle Seahawks | 21-10 | Ford Field - Detroit, MI |
| 2007 | X041XLI | Indianapolis Colts | Chicago Bears | 29-17 | Dolphin Stadium - Miami, FL |
| 2008 | X042XLII | New York Giants | New England Patriots | 17-14 | Univ. of Phoenix Stadium - Glendale, AZ |
| 2009 | X043XLIII | Pittsburgh Steelers | Arizona Cardinals | 27-23 | Raymond James Stadium - Tampa, FL |
| 2010 | X044XLIV | New Orleans Saints | Indianapolis Colts | 31-17 | Sun Life Stadium - Miami Gardens, FL |
| 2011 | X045XLV | Green Bay Packers | Pittsburgh Steelers | 31-25 | Cowboys Stadium - Arlington, TX |